Today is a wonderful time for anyone interested in Cloud Computing to be working with the US government. On the one hand, the government considers Cloud to be strategically important, and they already have a track record as an early adopter of Cloud Computing on a grand scale. On the other hand, the government is also in the unique position of being able to drive standards for the approach—and in fact, they are even responsible for establishing the most widely adopted definition of Cloud Computing.

The federal agency who has taken this leadership position is the National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST), an agency of the US Department of Commerce. NIST’s formal definition of Cloud Computing is already well known—“a model for enabling ubiquitous, convenient, on-demand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources (e.g., networks, servers, storage, applications and services) that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction.” Concise as that definition is, it only marks the beginning of the work NIST is doing to formalize and standardize the full breadth of Cloud Computing approaches, both within the government as well as for the world at large.

I learned about the breadth of NIST’s work on Cloud last week, when I had the pleasure of attending the NIST Cloud Computing Forum & Workshop. They are leading a cross-industry effort to “provide thought leadership and guidance around the cloud computing paradigm to catalyze its use within industry and government. NIST aims to shorten the adoption cycle, which will enable near-term cost savings and increased ability to quickly create and deploy enterprise applications. NIST aims to foster Cloud Computing systems and practices that support interoperability, portability, and security requirements that are appropriate and achievable for important usage scenarios.” To this end, they have followed up their formal definition with a Cloud Computing Technology Roadmap, which consists of three volumes: requirements to further US government adoption, information for Cloud adopters, and technical considerations for government Cloud Computing deployment decisions. They have also published a Cloud Computing reference architecture and standards roadmap.

To be sure, NIST has generated a daunting quantity of information here—but ignore these documents at your peril. If you work for a US government agency, then you likely have a mandate to move toward Cloud Computing, and NIST spells out many of the details. But even if you have nothing to do with the government,  it’s important to remember that NIST is also a standards body in its own right, as well as a coordinating agency for other standards bodies. No other group or agency anywhere else in the world has achieved the same leadership position with respect to today’s nascent Cloud standards efforts.

One of the main reasons NIST is able to maintain this position is because they have an inclusive approach. Want to contribute? You’re welcome to. Have an issue with something in one of the documents? Then let them know. After all, one of the reasons they’ve generated so much content is because they have so many contributors, not just from the government, but from people around the world.

Even ZapThink isn’t above joining the fray. We’ve reviewed NIST’s documents in the context of ZapThink’s eye for agile enterprise architecture, and we’ve identified a missing link. Of course, looking at something and trying to identify what’s missing is always difficult, especially when so many contributors have already pored over the material so carefully. The trick is to break out of “horseless carriage” patterns of thinking: instead of considering the Cloud to be little more than an outsourced, virtualized data center, put on your architect’s hat and consider how Cloud Computing’s unique characteristics will change how you do architecture.

NIST’s Cloud Deployment Scenarios

I found this missing link when I reviewed the Cloud deployment scenarios in the NIST Standards Roadmap document. Here is their diagram illustrating the eight generic deployment scenarios that they identified:

Generic Cloud Computing Deployment Scenarios

Generic Cloud Computing Deployment Scenarios (Source: NIST)

They sort the various deployment scenarios into three categories:

Single Cloud

  • Scenario 1: Deployment on a single Cloud
  • Scenario 2: Manage resources on a single Cloud
  • Scenario 3: Interface enterprise systems to a single Cloud
  • Scenario 4: Enterprise systems migrated or replaced on a single Cloud

Multiple Clouds (serially, one at a time)

  • Scenario 5: Migration between Clouds
  • Scenario 6: Interface across multiple Clouds
  • Scenario 7: Work with a selected Clouds

Multiple Clouds (simultaneously, more than one at a time)

  • Scenario 8: Operate across multiple Clouds

From ZapThink’s perspective, the most interesting of these are scenarios 1, 3, and 4, because they consider the relationships between enterprise systems and the Cloud. ZapThink has written about these relationships before, most recently in The Keys to Enterprise Public Cloud, but also back in mid-2010, when we discussed Cloud Architecture’s Missing Link.

The missing link we pointed out in that ZapFlash was the ability to compose Cloud-based Services with on-premise Services as part of an enterprise SOA effort. It could be argued, however, that composing Cloud-based Services falls under Scenario 3, since Services are a type of interface. But there’s more to this story—and to understand how the NIST folks missed it, it’s important to follow their line of reasoning.

NIST’s Blind Spot

NIST has divided their Cloud standards efforts into three categories: interoperability, portability, and security. Interoperability standards are the most straightforward, especially for anyone who has worked with Web Services, which of course are little more than standards-based interfaces intended to promote interoperability and loose coupling.

Portability standards are more complicated, because NIST considers both application portability and data portability. In the Cloud context, application portability centers on the ability to move virtual machine (VM) instances from one Cloud to another. Data portability, however, is more difficult, because applications process different kinds of data, and those data flow throughout an entire system. For one organization, data portability might mean moving a single database from one Cloud to another, but for a different organization, the requirement might be for the portability of an entire SaaS application, along with all of its distributed data.

NIST’s focus on interoperability and portability (and security, of course, which is an entire conversation in its own right) makes perfect sense in light of their focus on standards, since the standardization of these three capabilities will go a long way in furthering NIST’s core mission. So it’s no wonder that their three Cloud deployment scenarios that involve enterprise systems consist of deploying or migrating to a Cloud (facilitated by portability standards), or interfacing with a Cloud (facilitated by interoperability standards).

It should come as no surprise, therefore, that NIST missed another deployment scenario: building applications that leverage both on-premise and Cloud-based capabilities, where those applications rely upon more than interoperability, portability, and the ubiquitous security.

Building applications that are compositions of Cloud-based and on-premise Services is a simple example, but doesn’t go far enough, because even this scenario falls into the “horseless carriage” trap of considering the Cloud to be nothing more than a virtualized data center. Factor elasticity into the equation, however, and we must consider new approaches to architecting such applications that go beyond considerations of interoperability and portability.

Building the Cloud’s Inherent Elasticity into Hybrid Applications

More than any other characteristic, elasticity distinguishes true Clouds from simple virtualized data centers. If your app requires more resources, the Cloud will provision those resources automatically, and then release them when you’re done with them—until you need them again. Furthermore, those elastic resources may be among any of the different types of Cloud resources (networks, servers, storage, applications and Services,  as per the NIST definition), or any combination thereof.

As a result, when you architect your app, you don’t know how many of each of these resources you will be using at any point in time, since the number can change with no warning. You must take this change into account when architecting your data, your middleware, your execution environments, your application logic, and your presentation tier—in other words, your entire distributed application.

Cloud providers do their best to hide the underlying complexity inherent in delivering elastic infrastructure. But when you’re building a hybrid app—that is, one that includes Cloud-based as well as on-premise capabilities—your architects must have deeper knowledge of the underlying capabilities of the Cloud environment than Cloud providers are typically comfortable revealing. In other words, even once Cloud interoperability and portability standards mature, architects will still require additional information about the underlying capabilities of their Cloud environments that such standards won’t cover.

The ZapThink Take

This ZapFlash may leave you wanting more—namely, how precisely do you architect with the Cloud in mind? Unfortunately, there isn’t enough room for the answer to that question in this ZapFlash, but fear not, we’ll be laying out more details in the weeks and months to come.

Can’t wait? Then come to our Licensed ZapThink Architect SOA & Cloud course in San Diego January 16-19. We’ll dive deep into architecting with the Cloud, as we enjoy warm breezes off the Pacific from our lush venue by Seaforth Marina on Quivira Basin. Or better yet, take advantage of ZapThink’s new Cloud Competency Center by dropping us a line at info@zapthink.com. We’re here to help!

 

Discussion
38 comments for “Architecting Beyond Cloud Computing’s Horseless Carriage”
Cloud Computing by ramesh.nethi - Pearltrees Avatar

[...] Home » Research » ZapFlash » Architecting Beyond Cloud Computing’s Horseless Carriage Today is a wonderful time for anyone interested in Cloud Computing to be working with the US government. On the one hand, the government considers Cloud to be strategically important, and they already have a track record as an early adopter of Cloud Computing on a grand scale. On the other hand, the government is also in the unique position of being able to drive standards for the approach—and in fact, they are even responsible for establishing the most widely adopted definition of Cloud Computing. The federal agency who has taken this leadership position is the National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST), an agency of the US Department of Commerce. Architecting Beyond Cloud Computing’s Horseless Carriage | ZapThink [...]

Posted by Cloud Computing by ramesh.nethi - Pearltrees | December 22, 2011
life insurance claim lawyer attorney law firm Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

www.recycletotes.com Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by www.recycletotes.com | July 29, 2016
Calile Malouf Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Calile Malouf | August 1, 2016
Optimierung Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Optimierung | August 3, 2016
job openings for freshers Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by job openings for freshers | August 9, 2016
adu ayam Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by adu ayam | August 12, 2016
texas holdem poker online Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by texas holdem poker online | August 12, 2016
texas holdem poker free game Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by texas holdem poker free game | August 12, 2016
Buy Steroids Online Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Find More Informations here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Buy Steroids Online | August 13, 2016
cricket games india cricket-games.co.in Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by cricket games india cricket-games.co.in | August 16, 2016
кошерные рецепты Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by кошерные рецепты | August 17, 2016
Cora Compton Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More Infos here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Cora Compton | August 19, 2016
Printing Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] There you will find 71117 more Infos: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Printing | August 21, 2016
satta matka Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by satta matka | August 22, 2016
Margaret Cunniffe is an Australian Fraudster based in Melbourne Victoria who is a lying drunkard who creates the facade of a rich person by drinking champagne and living the highlife. Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Joseph de Saram#Rhodium Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Joseph de Saram#Rhodium | August 26, 2016
Agen Bandarq Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] There you will find 75583 more Infos: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Agen Bandarq | August 31, 2016
yandex ankara Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More Infos here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by yandex ankara | September 1, 2016
Imola Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More Infos here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Imola | September 2, 2016
economics tuition Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by economics tuition | September 3, 2016
yandex ankara Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] There you will find 46035 more Infos: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by yandex ankara | September 4, 2016
yandex ankara Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by yandex ankara | September 10, 2016
سفارش سایت Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by سفارش سایت | September 18, 2016
طراحی وب Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] There you will find 93613 more Infos: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by طراحی وب | September 22, 2016
optimierung Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More Infos here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by optimierung | September 22, 2016
free hgh Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by free hgh | September 23, 2016
venus factor Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by venus factor | September 26, 2016
make money teaching on udemy Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by make money teaching on udemy | October 1, 2016
Imprimiss changing the rules Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Imprimiss changing the rules | October 14, 2016
Best Newspaper in India Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Best Newspaper in India | October 21, 2016
joe de saram Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by joe de saram | October 24, 2016
para para dinle Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by para para dinle | October 30, 2016
flexipay Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by flexipay | October 31, 2016
wibforum Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Read More here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by wibforum | November 2, 2016
Best Newspaper in India Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Informations on that Topic: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Best Newspaper in India | November 2, 2016
Best Newspaper in India Avatar

... [Trackback]

[...] Find More Informations here: zapthink.com/2011/11/08/architecting-beyond-cloud-computings-horseless-carriage/ [...]

Posted by Best Newspaper in India | November 2, 2016
FALKIRK ON SITE COMPUTER SUPPORT BUISNESS FALKIRK, ONS-SITE - COMPUTER SUPPORT - BUSINESS - FALKIRK Avatar

FALKIRK ON SITE COMPUTER SUPPORT BUISNESS FALKIRK, ONS-SITE - COMPUTER SUPPORT - BUSINESS - FALKIRK

[...]always a significant fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but do not get a whole lot of link adore from[...]